I was told that I’m not being compassionate because I want closed borders.
Community answers are sorted based on votes. The higher the vote, the further up an answer is.
Sorry for the long answer - lots of moving parts. The Bible speaks of borders, but not of "closed borders." God promises Abraham to give his descendants land "from the Wadi of Egypt to the great river, the Euphrates--" (Gen. 15:18). Again in Exodus, God says "I will fix your boundary from the Red Sea to the sea of the Philistines, and from the wilderness to the River Euphrates;" (Exodus 23:31) These are national boundaries that help countries exist next to each other without encroaching on each other's resources. All nations have, and always will defend their boundaries if they happen to be encroached upon by a neighbor. The Biblical world was also full of nomadic people. Many individuals were on the move with their flocks in search of adequate grazing lands (Gen. 37:17). This would be commonplace. Those with their flocks though had to honor the farmers and their fields. There were laws against illegal grazing (Ex. 22:5). Israel - as a nation - sits right on the major highway between Mesopotamia and Egypt so foreign travelers are the norm. Scholars refer to Israel as "the land between" - because they were constantly caught in the battles for dominance between Egypt and Mesopotamia (Babylon or Assyria). God is also VERY concerned with the welfare of the "alien/stranger" living among the Israelites (Ex. 23:9). The reason is that the "stranger" has no natural support system around them and may also have to overcome a language barrier. This makes them prone to being taken advantage of. The reason God gives the Israelites is that "you were strangers in Egypt once" and were mistreated. You didn't like it so don't do it to someone else. The Hebrew word (v'ahavta) - translates "and you shall love..." only shows up four times in the entire Old Testament. Two times the object is God "and you shall love the LORD your God" (Deut. 6:5 and Deut. 11:1). The other two times are in Leviticus chapter 19: "And you shall love your neighbor" (Lev. 19:18) and "and you shall love the STRANGER" (Lev. 19:33-34). God is concerned that you treat the stranger/alien lovingly. Now - lets deal with the idea of compassion. Compassion is the desire to reduce suffering and is a component of empathy. Empathy is the idea of being able to identify with someone else's feelings. Compassion then moves you to act in an attempt to reduce suffering. Compassion though - must do what is best for the "whole person" receiving the help. Compassion must always be balanced with judgment (the ability to discern right/wrong). When your son is 2-months-old and wants to lie around and eat you act with compassion and feed him. When your son is 32 years old and wants to lay around the basement and eat - you use judgment and tell him to "get his act together!" Too much compassion for a 32-year-old who is fully capable may actually be destructive. You can "empathize" with someone but not act out of compassion when judgment tells you that action is not in the best interest of that person or the community at large. Jesus is a combination of compassion for those truly in need (Matt. 9:36) and judgment for those who are not (Mark 10:22). Paul is a combination of compassion (Col. 3:12) and judgment (2 Thess. 3:10). Matters of immigration are complex. There is no one "right answer." There never is. It is situationally dependent and must be a balance of compassion and judgment. Empathy is always good. It means you can see the "other" as a full human being with needs, wants, desires, etc. But to empathize does not mean we must always act out of compassion. Unfortunately, "acts of compassion" are often confused with "love." When acts of compassion are authentic and truly in need - they are wonderful. But acts of compassion that are not "truly" needed can be destructive and lead to unintended consequences. Striving toward a "Christ-like" character can help us stand firmly in the tension-filled gap between compassion and judgment.
I humbly submit for your consideration an answer to the current open borders immigration sideshow put forth by the faculty lounge commandos and their fellow traveling companions in the intelligentsia media. It is addressed in the second book of the Bible, Exodus chapter 20. These laws were written by the very finger of God in stone, for man everywhere and for all time, and were placed into the ark with a purpose. (Exodus 20:15) "STEAL" take without the owner's consent i.e. illegally receive some benefit not do you at another's expense. (Exodus 20:17) "COVET" wish, long, or crave for something, begrudge, envy, drool over that which you want, but is not yours to have outside of His will. "ILLEGAL" prohibited by law or by official or accepted rules. Words do in fact have meaning; now a few facts for your consideration on this matter: 1. America is a land of LEGAL immigrants and starting in 1892 and ending in 1954 only about twelve million LEGAL immigrants entered the USA through Ellis Island. 2. The true purpose of this Ellis (remember it's an Island) was to isolate any foreign diseases and treat them at the island hospital, thus protecting the mainland citizen population from exposure to the diseases of the world or who knew what at the time. 3. The immigration and nationality act of 1965 enacted on June 30 1968 fundamentally changed a system that had been working since May 19 1921. Under the new quota system setup ninety percent of all future spots would be given to third world countries and only ten percent to the educated from industrialized nations. Now each year Ted Kennedy's reform brings over one million LEGAL third world immigrants and future Democratic voters in, but somehow that's still that's not enough. 4.We are a constitutional republic founded on the rule of law where we are all equally subject to its statutes as LEGALLY written and not as IDEOLOGICALLY wanted. I may disagree with the concept of abortion, but I will follow the law as written and continue working to legally change the law. (John 7:24) 5. Just because a thief breaks into your home and puts on your pajamas, somehow you are now required to make them part of your family, this is not logical and the Bible seems to have a bit to say on the future status of thieves and liars. Heaven has a strict immigration policy; hell is open borders friend. Bottom Line: Leftists love to play the Christianity/morality card back on us. In essence, leftists like to use our “Good Samaritan” tendencies to our own detriment. They have always had a strong tendency to be very charitable with your money and now they’d like to be charitable with your life and the lives of those you love. But a truly moral person doesn’t do a kindness at the expense of someone else’s safety or life! Robbing via open borders “Illegal immigration” another's nation's best and brightest future generations deprives those nations of their very much needed God-placed resources to affect the change that HIS plan requires, also does it not appear to be somewhat covertness in it's very nature? (Exodus 20:17; Romans 13:9) The scriptures contain rules that promote a moral civil order; whereas those of man promote a chorus of chaos. And in my humble opinion scripture foretold of the current age before us all, when many would be lovers of themselves, offended in some way, thus granting themselves a grievance license to seek whatever they desire from the pocket or property of another. (2 Timothy 3:2, Acts 5:29, Luke 6:26) "To be loving; does not mean or require one to be gullible." Jack Ten "The problem with open borders lunacy is that eventually you run out of other people's neighbourhoods. ' Jack Ten In the Lord's freedom and let no one deceive you................warrior on.
I will overlook the not so veiled political undertone of the question and concentrate on the most important element of the issue. The ‘closed borders’ term is a misnomer and anyone suggesting such policy is wasting valuable time and energy. A closed border is a border that prevents movement of people between different jurisdictions. Even the most oppressive governments, like North Korea, allows some type of movements of people across its border. Everyday millions of people travel in and out of US via hundreds of ports of entry. To create a closed borders society (as Utopian as it might sound to some) and eliminate all or most entries into the country is not only impossible, but if implemented would severely damage the country’s economy, kill millions of jobs and bankrupt the tourism and hospitality industries. So then ye are no more strangers and sojourners, but ye are fellow-citizens with the saints, and of the household of God (Eph 2:19) But we are citizens of heaven, where the Lord Jesus Christ lives. And we are eagerly waiting for him to return as our Savior (Phil 3:20)
All answers are REVIEWED and MODERATED.
Please ensure your answer MEETS all our guidelines.
A good answer provides new insight and perspective. Here are guidelines to help facilitate a meaningful learning experience for everyone.